Dividing Retirement Accounts in a Florida Divorce

Dividing Retirement Accounts in a Florida Divorce

401(k)s, IRAs, Pensions and QDROs: A Guide for Palm Beach County Spouses

For many couples, retirement savings are the largest asset after the house, and in long marriages they are often larger than the house. Florida treats retirement benefits built up during the marriage as marital property, so they are on the table in almost every divorce. Dividing them is not as simple as writing “50/50” in a settlement. Each type of plan has its own rules, its own administrator and its own tax treatment, and an order that does not satisfy the plan can leave a spouse with an award they cannot collect.

This guide explains how a Florida court classifies, values and divides retirement accounts, what a QDRO is and when you need one, and the mistakes that most often cost people money. It is written for spouses in Palm Beach County and the surrounding counties, where our office regularly handles divorces involving executive plans, professional practice plans, Florida Retirement System benefits, federal and military pensions, and large IRAs.

At a glance

  • Retirement benefits accrued during the marriage, vested or not, are marital assets under § 61.075(6)(a)1.e. and § 61.076(1), Florida Statutes.
  • Balances you brought into the marriage are generally nonmarital, but you have to be able to trace them.
  • 401(k)s, 403(b)s and private pensions are divided with a Qualified Domestic Relations Order (QDRO). IRAs are not; they are divided by a transfer incident to divorce.
  • Federal, military, Florida Retirement System and city police and fire pensions each follow their own rules.
  • A dollar in a pre-tax account is not worth the same as a dollar in a bank account. Taxes should be part of every settlement conversation.

1. Retirement benefits earned during the marriage are marital property

Florida’s equitable distribution statute lists “all vested and nonvested benefits, rights, and funds accrued during the marriage” in retirement, pension, profit-sharing, annuity, deferred compensation and insurance plans as marital assets. Section 61.076(1) repeats the rule and makes those benefits subject to equitable distribution. The Florida Supreme Court reached the same conclusion before the statute existed, holding in Diffenderfer v. Diffenderfer, 491 So. 2d 265 (Fla. 1986), that a spouse’s pension or retirement benefits must be considered a marital asset.

Two points in that language matter more than people expect:

  • “Nonvested” benefits count. An unvested employer match, a pension you cannot yet collect, or a deferred compensation award that pays out in future years can still be marital to the extent it was earned during the marriage.
  • “Accrued during the marriage” is the dividing line. The court divides the marital portion, not the whole account, which is why the dates in your case matter so much.

As with every other marital asset, the court starts from the premise that the division should be equal and can make an unequal division only if the statutory factors justify it. Our page on equitable distribution in a Florida divorce explains that process in more detail.

2. Separating the marital portion from the nonmarital portion

Most retirement accounts that come into a divorce are mixed. A spouse may have started a 401(k) years before the wedding, kept contributing during the marriage, rolled it into an IRA after a job change, and kept investing after the divorce was filed. Florida law sorts those pieces out using a few rules:

  • Premarital balances are generally nonmarital under § 61.075(6)(b)1.
  • Income from nonmarital assets is generally nonmarital under § 61.075(6)(b)3, unless the spouses treated, used or relied on it as a marital asset.
  • Growth caused by marital contributions or marital effort is marital under § 61.075(6)(a).
  • The cut-off date. Under § 61.075(7), the last date for classifying an asset as marital is the earliest of the date of a valid separation agreement, a date that agreement sets, or the date the petition for dissolution was filed. Contributions after that date are generally the employee’s own.
  • The valuation date. The same subsection lets the judge choose the date or dates that are just and equitable for valuing assets, and different assets can be valued on different dates. For accounts invested in the market, the gap between the cut-off date and the day the account is actually split can be worth a great deal.

The spouse claiming that part of an account is nonmarital carries the burden of proving it. In practice that means statements from around the date of marriage and a paper trail through every rollover and transfer. Rollovers between employers are where tracing most often breaks down, so it is worth requesting old statements early in the discovery process. A valid prenuptial agreement can also change these default rules, so review it before anything else.

3. The type of plan decides how it is divided

The single most important question about a retirement asset is what kind of plan it is. The table below summarizes the main categories we see in Palm Beach County cases.

Plan type How it is usually valued What divides it
401(k), 403(b), profit-sharing and other employer defined contribution plans Account balance on the valuation date, plus or minus investment gains and losses QDRO under ERISA and Internal Revenue Code § 414(p)
Traditional, Roth, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs Account balance on the valuation date Transfer incident to divorce under Internal Revenue Code § 408(d)(6); no QDRO
Private-sector pensions and cash balance plans Present value by an actuary, or a coverture fraction applied to future payments QDRO
Florida Retirement System (FRS) Pension Plan and Investment Plan Coverture fraction (Pension Plan) or account balance (Investment Plan) A qualified order approved by the plan, with separate requirements for each FRS plan
Federal civilian annuities (FERS and CSRS) Coverture fraction or fixed amount Court order acceptable for processing by OPM under 5 C.F.R. Part 838
Thrift Savings Plan (TSP) Account balance Retirement benefits court order under 5 C.F.R. Part 1653
Military retired pay Percentage or formula applied to disposable retired pay Order meeting the Uniformed Services Former Spouses’ Protection Act, 10 U.S.C. § 1408, and § 61.076(2)–(3)
City police and firefighter pensions (Chapters 175 and 185 plans) Present value or coverture fraction Often cannot be divided by QDRO; usually an offset or direct payments from the member
Nonqualified deferred compensation and executive plans Depends on plan terms, vesting and payout schedule Plan terms control; often an offset or a payment “if, as and when” the employee is paid

4. Pensions: present value, coverture fractions and deferred distribution

A 401(k) has a balance on a statement. A pension is a promise of monthly payments in the future, which makes it harder to value and to split. Florida courts generally use one of two approaches:

  • Immediate offset. An actuary calculates the present value of the marital portion of the pension. The employee keeps the pension and the other spouse receives other assets of equal value. This gives a clean break, but it trades a guaranteed future income stream for assets available today, and the result is only as good as the actuarial assumptions.
  • Deferred distribution. The court divides each payment when it is actually made, using a coverture fraction. If 15 of the employee’s 25 years of credited service fell within the marriage, 60 percent of the benefit is marital, and an equal division gives the former spouse 30 percent of it.

The Florida Supreme Court has said that valuing retirement benefits is fact-intensive and that no formula can capture every consideration of fairness. In Boyett v. Boyett, 703 So. 2d 451 (Fla. 1997), it approved a ruling that the valuation of a retirement plan should exclude contributions made after the final judgment. For that reason, a well-drafted order spells out whether the former spouse’s share is based on the benefit as of the cut-off date or the benefit actually paid at retirement, and how later raises and service are handled.

A pension order should also address the features that are easy to forget:

  • Survivor benefits. If the employee dies before retirement, the former spouse’s share can disappear unless the QDRO treats the former spouse as the surviving spouse for pre-retirement and post-retirement survivor benefits.
  • Early retirement subsidies, cost-of-living increases and DROP accounts. Whether the former spouse shares in them should be stated, not assumed.
  • Shared payment or separate interest. Some plans let the former spouse take a separate benefit based on their own life expectancy. Others only allow a share of the employee’s payments, which end when the employee dies.

5. How a QDRO works, step by step

A Qualified Domestic Relations Order is a court order that tells an employer retirement plan to pay part of a participant’s benefit to an “alternate payee,” usually the former spouse. The requirements come from federal law, ERISA § 206(d)(3) and Internal Revenue Code § 414(p). The plan administrator, not the judge, decides whether an order is “qualified,” and a QDRO cannot require a plan to pay a type or form of benefit the plan does not offer.

  1. Identify every plan and get its QDRO procedures. Most plans publish model language and procedures. Request them during the case, not after the final judgment.
  2. Write the settlement terms precisely. State whether the award is a percentage or a fixed dollar amount, the valuation date, whether gains and losses run until the account is split, how any outstanding plan loan is treated, who gets survivor benefits, and who pays the preparation and plan review fees.
  3. Submit a draft for preapproval if the plan allows it. Fixing problems before the judge signs saves weeks.
  4. Have the court enter the order. The final judgment should reserve jurisdiction to enter and, if necessary, amend QDROs.
  5. Send a certified copy to the plan and follow up until the plan confirms in writing that the order is qualified and the account has been divided.
  6. Choose what to do with the funds. An alternate payee can usually leave the money in the plan, roll it into their own IRA, or take some or all of it in cash.

Delay is the biggest risk. Until a plan has an order in hand, it pays benefits according to its own records, so a participant who withdraws money, retires, takes a loan or dies before the QDRO is entered can leave the former spouse chasing a judgment instead of collecting from the plan. Once a plan receives a domestic relations order, federal law requires it to separately account for the amounts at stake for up to 18 months while it decides whether the order qualifies. That protection only starts when the order arrives.

6. Dividing IRAs: no QDRO, but the paperwork still matters

IRAs are not employer plans, so they are not divided by QDRO. Instead, Internal Revenue Code § 408(d)(6) provides that transferring an interest in an IRA to a spouse or former spouse under a divorce or separation instrument is not a taxable transfer. The final judgment or marital settlement agreement should identify the account and the amount or percentage, and the transfer should be completed by the custodian, either by retitling the account or by a direct trustee-to-trustee transfer into an IRA in the receiving spouse’s name.

The common mistake is for the account owner to withdraw the money and write the other spouse a check. In Kirkpatrick v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2018-20, the Tax Court held that IRA withdrawals the husband used to pay his wife were taxable to him and did not qualify as a transfer incident to divorce. Keep the funds inside the IRA system, and keep Roth money in a Roth account.

7. Tax traps: a dollar in a 401(k) is not a dollar in the bank

Florida has no state income tax, but federal income tax still applies to most retirement withdrawals. That affects how assets should be compared in a settlement:

  • Pre-tax accounts carry a built-in tax bill. $500,000 in a traditional 401(k) is not equivalent to $500,000 in a checking account or a Roth IRA. Spouses often negotiate how to account for that difference, but a court will generally not speculate about taxes that are not certain to be owed.
  • The QDRO penalty exception. Distributions to an alternate payee under a QDRO from an employer plan are exempt from the 10 percent additional tax on early withdrawals under Internal Revenue Code § 72(t)(2)(C), even if the alternate payee is under 59½. Regular income tax still applies.
  • The exception does not follow the money into an IRA. It does not apply to IRA distributions, so a spouse who needs cash should usually take it from the plan before rolling the rest into an IRA, not after.
  • Withholding. Cash distributions from employer plans that could have been rolled over are generally subject to 20 percent mandatory federal withholding, so plan for the difference between the award and the check.
  • Plan loans. An outstanding 401(k) loan reduces the account’s real value and should be addressed expressly, either as a marital debt or as a reduction to the balance being divided.

Because retirement assets also produce income, the way they are divided can affect an alimony claim. Property division and support should be planned together.

8. Federal, military and Florida public-employee plans

Federal employees: FERS, CSRS and the TSP

Federal civilian annuities are divided by a court order that the Office of Personnel Management accepts for processing under 5 C.F.R. Part 838. OPM applies its regulations literally, so model language matters. A former spouse survivor annuity must be expressly awarded in the order. The Thrift Savings Plan is handled separately, through a retirement benefits court order that meets 5 C.F.R. Part 1653.

Military retired pay

The Uniformed Services Former Spouses’ Protection Act lets Florida courts divide disposable military retired pay as property. Under the “10/10 rule,” a former spouse can receive payments directly from the Defense Finance and Accounting Service only if the marriage lasted at least 10 years overlapping 10 years of creditable service. The rule does not affect whether the award is valid, only how it is paid. Direct payments for property division are capped at 50 percent of disposable retired pay. Florida’s § 61.076(2) adds specific findings the final judgment must contain when the 10/10 rule is met.

Two other points come up often. Retired pay that a veteran waives to receive VA disability compensation is not disposable retired pay, and in Howell v. Howell, 581 U.S. 214 (2017), the U.S. Supreme Court held that state courts cannot order a veteran to reimburse a former spouse for that reduction. And if the judgment awards the former spouse Survivor Benefit Plan coverage, a “deemed election” generally must reach DFAS within one year of the court order requiring that coverage. Missing that deadline can cost the coverage permanently.

Florida Retirement System

Teachers, county employees and many other public workers in Palm Beach County are FRS members. The FRS Pension Plan, a defined benefit plan, and the FRS Investment Plan, a defined contribution plan, are administered separately and have separate order requirements. The Investment Plan accepts draft orders for preliminary review, which is worth doing.

City police and firefighter pensions

Many municipal police and fire pension plans are governed by Chapters 175 and 185, Florida Statutes. Section 185.25 states that municipal police pension benefits are unassignable and not subject to legal process, and Florida courts have read that kind of language to prevent dividing these pensions by QDRO. The marital portion is still marital property, but the division usually has to be handled through an offset against other assets or an order requiring the member to pay the former spouse directly. Check the specific plan’s current rules early, because they affect the whole settlement.

9. Executive, physician and business-owner plans

In high-net-worth divorces, the hardest retirement assets are often not 401(k)s at all.

  • Nonqualified deferred compensation and supplemental executive retirement plans are usually not subject to QDROs and may not be transferable at all. They are typically divided by offset, or by requiring the employee to pay a share of each payout when it is received. Vesting schedules, forfeiture conditions and payout elections all affect value.
  • Practice and business plans. Physicians, attorneys and business owners often have cash balance plans, solo 401(k)s or SEP-IRAs, and the owner-spouse may also be the plan administrator. Contribution timing around the cut-off date, plan valuations and the owner’s control over the plan all deserve scrutiny.
  • Beneficiary designations. Under § 732.703, Florida Statutes, a designation of a former spouse as beneficiary of many nonprobate assets, including IRAs, becomes void when the marriage is dissolved, subject to exceptions. Federal law can override that rule for ERISA plans, which pay according to the plan documents (Egelhoff v. Egelhoff, 532 U.S. 141 (2001)). The safest course is to update every beneficiary designation as soon as the divorce is final, consistent with any obligations in the judgment.

What is different in Palm Beach County

Divorces in Palm Beach County are heard in the Fifteenth Judicial Circuit, and the retirement mix here is unusually broad. A single case can involve an FRS pension, a city firefighter pension, a federal annuity, military retired pay, and IRAs rolled over from out-of-state employers. Many residents also relocated here near or after retirement, which means pensions already in pay status, required minimum distributions, and accounts that were partly earned before the marriage or under another state’s law.

Practically, that means three things. Identify every plan in mandatory disclosure and get its procedures early. Make sure the marital settlement agreement or final judgment says exactly how each account is to be divided and that the court reserves jurisdiction over QDROs. And do not treat the QDRO as an afterthought once the final judgment is entered. Our Florida divorce roadmap shows where these steps fit in the overall case, and we work with clients from Palm Beach, Jupiter, Palm Beach Gardens, Wellington, Boca Raton and the rest of the county.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a QDRO to divide an IRA in a Florida divorce?
No. IRAs are divided by a transfer incident to divorce under Internal Revenue Code § 408(d)(6). The final judgment or settlement agreement should identify the IRA and the share to be transferred, and the custodian should move the funds directly into an IRA in the receiving spouse’s name.

Is the 401(k) I had before the marriage marital property?
The balance you had on the date of the marriage is generally nonmarital. Contributions made during the marriage, and growth on them, are generally marital. Whether growth on the premarital balance stays nonmarital depends on the facts, and you will need statements to trace it.

Can my spouse take cash from my 401(k) without the 10 percent early withdrawal penalty?
Yes. A former spouse who receives a distribution from an employer plan as an alternate payee under a QDRO is exempt from the 10 percent additional tax, although regular income tax still applies. The exception does not apply to IRAs, including an IRA the funds are later rolled into.

What happens if the QDRO is never completed?
The plan will keep paying benefits according to its own records. If the participant retires, withdraws funds or dies first, the former spouse may be left trying to enforce the judgment against the participant or an estate instead of collecting from the plan. Courts can enter QDROs after the final judgment, but waiting adds risk.

Can I keep my whole pension and give my spouse other assets instead?
Often, yes. This is called an offset. It requires a reliable present value of the marital portion of the pension, and the assets traded for it should be compared on an after-tax basis.

Talk with a Palm Beach County divorce attorney about your retirement accounts

Retirement accounts are often where the real value of a divorce settlement is won or lost, and the mistakes usually do not show up until years later. If you or your spouse has a 401(k), pension, FRS, federal or military benefit, executive plan or significant IRA, we can help you identify what is marital, value it correctly and make sure the division actually happens. Consultations are by appointment only.

Law Offices of James S. Cunha, P.A.
250 S. Australian Avenue, Suite 1402
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
(561) 429-3924 · Contact us online

This article provides general information about Florida law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Rules and procedures change; consult an attorney about your situation.

Scroll to Top