Dividing a Closely Held Business in a Florida Divorce

Dividing a Closely Held Business in a Florida Divorce

Family Companies, Professional Practices and Partnership Interests: A Guide for Palm Beach County Owners and Spouses

For many Palm Beach County couples, the most valuable thing they own is not the house or the brokerage account. It is a business: a medical or dental group, an insurance agency, a construction company, a family real estate partnership, or a stake in a company run with partners. It is also the hardest asset to divide. No statement shows what it is worth, one spouse usually controls the books, the same dollars can show up as both property and income, and the company often has co-owners who want nothing to do with the divorce.

This guide explains how a Florida court decides whether a business interest is marital, how the court values it, how goodwill is treated after the Legislature rewrote the rules in 2024, how the business affects alimony and child support, and how the other spouse can be paid without taking the company apart. It is written for owners and spouses in Palm Beach County and the surrounding counties, where our office regularly handles divorces involving professional practices, family companies and businesses with multiple owners.

At a glance

  • A business built during the marriage is a marital asset. Since July 1, 2024, § 61.075(6)(a)1.f., Florida Statutes, expressly lists “the marital interests in a closely held business” and requires the court to value them at fair market value.
  • A business you owned before the marriage stays nonmarital, but growth caused by either spouse’s efforts or by marital money during the marriage is marital under § 61.075(6)(a)1.b.
  • Enterprise goodwill is divided. Personal goodwill is not. The line between the two is often where the largest dollars in the case are won or lost.
  • The business also drives the support numbers. Owner salary, perks paid by the company and retained earnings all affect alimony and child support.
  • Courts rarely make former spouses co-owners. The usual result is that the owner keeps the business and the other spouse receives other assets or an equalizing payment, sometimes in secured installments.

1. A business built during the marriage is marital property

Florida’s equitable distribution statute starts from the premise that marital assets should be divided equally, and it presumes that anything acquired during the marriage is marital unless shown otherwise (§ 61.075(1) and (8)). A company formed during the marriage, shares bought with marital money and a partnership interest earned during the marriage all fall into that category, regardless of whose name is on the paperwork. Our page on equitable distribution in a Florida divorce explains the overall process.

In 2024 the Legislature added a provision written specifically for businesses. Chapter 2024-237, Laws of Florida (House Bill 521), took effect July 1, 2024 and created § 61.075(6)(a)1.f. It does four things:

  • It names the asset. The marital interests in a closely held business are a marital asset.
  • It sets the standard of value. The standard is fair market value, defined as the price at which the interest would change hands between a willing and able buyer and a willing and able seller, neither under any compulsion to buy or sell, both with reasonable knowledge of the relevant facts.
  • It defines enterprise goodwill. Goodwill that is separate and distinct from the continued presence and reputation of the owner spouse is enterprise goodwill, a marital asset the court must value.
  • It changes how noncompetes are treated. The court must consider evidence that a sale would require a covenant not to compete, but that evidence alone does not prevent the court from finding enterprise goodwill.

The act does not say whether it reaches cases that were already pending when it took effect. If your case was filed before July 1, 2024, ask your attorney how that question affects you.

Two dates in § 61.075(7) matter more in business cases than almost anywhere else:

  • The cut-off date. Assets are classified as marital or nonmarital as of the earliest of a valid separation agreement, a date that agreement sets, or the date the petition for dissolution was filed.
  • The valuation date. The judge chooses the date or dates that are just and equitable, and different assets can be valued on different dates. A company whose value rises or falls with the owner’s work after the filing date can be worth very different amounts depending on which date the court picks.

In a contested case, the final judgment must identify and individually value each significant marital asset, and those findings must rest on competent substantial evidence (§ 61.075(3)). A judge cannot simply pick a number. Each side needs admissible valuation evidence, and a business valuation unsupported by the record is a frequent reason Florida appellate courts send divorce judgments back for another look.

2. Businesses started before the marriage: active versus passive growth

A business you owned before the wedding is nonmarital under § 61.075(6)(b)1, and shares you received by gift or inheritance, such as stock in a parent’s company, are nonmarital under § 61.075(6)(b)2. That is where the analysis starts, not where it ends.

Under § 61.075(6)(a)1.b., the “enhancement in value and appreciation” of a nonmarital asset is marital if it resulted from the efforts of either spouse during the marriage or from marital funds or other marital assets. An owner who spends the marriage running and growing a premarital company, a spouse who works in the business without pay, and marital savings used to buy equipment or cover payroll can each turn part of a nonmarital company’s growth into a marital asset.

  • Who has to prove it. The Fourth District Court of Appeal, which hears appeals from Palm Beach County, has held that the spouse claiming the enhancement carries the burden of proving it. Pereboom v. Pereboom, 959 So. 2d 1205 (Fla. 4th DCA 2007). Once the owner shows the company was premarital, the other spouse has to show that it grew because of marital effort or money, and by how much. In practice that requires a valuation as of the date of the marriage (or acquisition) as well as one as of the valuation date.
  • Active growth is marital. The Fourth District has treated appreciation in family-company stock as marital where the spouse held significant management roles. Robbie v. Robbie, 654 So. 2d 616 (Fla. 4th DCA 1995); Minton v. Minton, 698 So. 2d 936 (Fla. 4th DCA 1997).
  • Passive growth is not. Appreciation that did not result from marital effort or marital funds, such as growth driven by the market or by other people’s work, stays nonmarital. Oxley v. Oxley, 695 So. 2d 364 (Fla. 4th DCA 1997). In Witt-Bahls v. Bahls, 193 So. 3d 35 (Fla. 4th DCA 2016), the court declined to adopt a bright-line rule and focused on whether the owner’s efforts were the kind that move appreciation into the marital column.
  • Income from the business. Income from a nonmarital asset is generally nonmarital, unless the spouses treated, used or relied on it as a marital asset (§ 61.075(6)(b)3). Distributions deposited into a joint account and spent on family expenses are the classic example of income that has crossed over.

Owners who drew a modest salary and reinvested in a premarital company should expect the other spouse to argue that the marital labor was paid for in company value rather than in wages. Records showing what the owner actually did, what other managers did and what drove the growth are often the whole case on this issue.

3. How Florida courts value a business

Fair market value is now the statutory standard, but the statute does not choose a method. That is left to the evidence, which almost always means competing valuation experts. The court can accept one expert, accept parts of each, or reject both, as long as the number it lands on is supported by the evidence. The table below summarizes the three main approaches experts use.

ApproachHow it worksWhere it tends to fitWhat to watch
Income approach (capitalized earnings or discounted cash flow)Converts the company’s normalized future earnings into a present value using a risk-adjusted rateEstablished, profitable companies with predictable earningsThe owner-compensation adjustment, the capitalization rate, and whether personal goodwill is built into the earnings stream
Market approach (guideline transactions or companies)Compares the business to sales of similar businesses or to similar companiesIndustries with good transaction data, such as insurance agencies and some professional practicesComparable sales in which the seller kept influence over the business, for example by staying on after the sale, may reflect personal goodwill. Walton v. Walton, 657 So. 2d 1214 (Fla. 4th DCA 1995)
Asset approach (adjusted net assets)Restates the company’s assets and liabilities at fair market valueHolding companies, real estate entities, capital-heavy businesses, and businesses whose goodwill is mostly personalReal estate and equipment appraisals, related-party loans, and contingent liabilities

Whatever the method, several issues come up in nearly every case:

  • Normalizing the books. Experts adjust the financial statements for an owner salary above or below market, personal expenses run through the company, one-time items, and related-party arrangements such as rent paid to an entity the owner also controls.
  • Leaving nothing out. In Bair v. Bair, 214 So. 3d 750 (Fla. 2d DCA 2017), the court held that valuing a company while excluding major assets it owned, there real property, was plain error. The same opinion rejected counting retained earnings once inside the company’s value and again as cash available for distribution.
  • Discounts. A minority interest, or an interest that would be hard to sell, may be worth less than its proportionate share of the whole company. Florida trial courts have discretion to apply a marketability discount when expert testimony supports it. Erp v. Erp, 976 So. 2d 1234 (Fla. 2d DCA 2008). Whether a discount fits depends on the size of the interest, who controls the company, and the transfer restrictions in its governing documents.
  • Taxes on a hypothetical sale. Because a sale usually is not contemplated, courts are generally reluctant to deduct taxes that would be owed only if the business were sold. If a sale is actually required, the tax picture changes and should be part of the evidence.

Our article on the role of experts in contested high-asset divorces explains how valuation experts and forensic accountants fit into a case.

4. Goodwill: what is divided and what is not

Florida courts describe goodwill as the “expectation of continued public patronage.” Held v. Held, 912 So. 2d 637 (Fla. 4th DCA 2005). In many service businesses it is most of the value. The leading case is Thompson v. Thompson, 576 So. 2d 267 (Fla. 1991), which involved a law practice. The Florida Supreme Court held that goodwill is a marital asset only if it exists separately from the reputation or continued presence of the spouse who owns the business.

  • Enterprise goodwill belongs to the business: its name, location, systems, staff, contracts and referral sources that would keep producing revenue if the owner left. It is divided.
  • Personal goodwill belongs to the person: the owner’s own skill, reputation and relationships. It cannot be sold apart from the owner and is not divided.

Fourth District decisions applying Thompson guide Palm Beach County judges. In Held, the court reversed a valuation of the husband’s insurance agency that folded his personal goodwill into the value of the business. In Christians v. Christians, 732 So. 2d 47 (Fla. 4th DCA 1999), it found no enterprise goodwill in a trapeze business whose goodwill rested on the husband’s reputation and continued involvement. And in Schmidt v. Schmidt, 120 So. 3d 31 (Fla. 4th DCA 2013), it again required that personal goodwill be removed from the value assigned to the business.

What changed in 2024. For years, the fact that a buyer would insist on a noncompete from the owner was treated as strong evidence that the goodwill was personal. Some courts called it “telling evidence” of a lack of enterprise goodwill. Under the amended statute, the court still has to consider noncompete evidence, but that evidence alone no longer rules out enterprise goodwill. One of the first appellate decisions in that setting, Donahue v. Donahue, 2024 WL 4795980 (Fla. 2d DCA Nov. 15, 2024), upheld treating all of the goodwill in an advisory business as enterprise goodwill where the client relationships predated the husband and did not fall away when the prior owner left.

Multi-owner practices. In Rosenberg v. Rosenberg, 391 So. 3d 975 (Fla. 5th DCA 2024), the court held that the personal goodwill of every physician-shareholder in a large medical group, not just the divorcing spouse, must be excluded when valuing the spouse’s interest.

For an owner, the practical lesson is that a personal-goodwill argument needs evidence: client concentration, referral sources tied to the owner, what happens to revenue when the owner is absent, and real transaction data. For the other spouse, it means looking hard at the institutional features of the business. Our article on celebrity goodwill in a Florida divorce applies the same rules to public figures.

5. The business as an income source: alimony, child support and double counting

A business is property, but it is also usually the family’s main source of income. That second role can matter as much as the first.

  • Business income. For child support, § 61.30(2)(a)3, Florida Statutes, counts income from self-employment, partnerships, close corporations and independent contracts, defined as gross receipts minus the ordinary and necessary expenses required to produce the income. Expenses that are not truly necessary to earn the income can be challenged.
  • Perks count. Reimbursed expenses and in-kind payments count as income to the extent they reduce living expenses (§ 61.30(2)(a)13). A company car, phone, travel, meals and insurance paid by the business can all add to the owner’s income for support purposes.
  • Alimony uses the same definitions. Under § 61.08, the court considers each party’s resources and income, including income generated from both marital and nonmarital assets. Durational alimony is capped at the lesser of the recipient’s reasonable need or 35 percent of the difference between the parties’ net incomes, with net income calculated under § 61.30(2) and (3). How the owner’s business income is measured therefore moves the ceiling as well as the award.
  • Length limits. After the 2023 amendments, the available forms are temporary, bridge-the-gap, rehabilitative and durational alimony. Durational alimony generally cannot exceed 50 percent of the length of a short-term marriage (under 10 years), 60 percent of a moderate-term marriage (10 to 20 years) or 75 percent of a long-term marriage (20 years or more). Our durational alimony calculator shows how the limits work.

Retained earnings. Owners of S corporations and other pass-through entities pay tax on profits whether or not the profits are distributed. In Zold v. Zold, 911 So. 2d 1222 (Fla. 2005), the Florida Supreme Court held that undistributed pass-through income retained for corporate purposes is not income for alimony, child support or attorney’s fees, and that the shareholder spouse bears the burden of proving the earnings were retained for corporate purposes. An owner who controls distributions and stops taking them once a divorce is on the horizon should expect that decision to be examined closely.

Double counting. When an expert values a business by capitalizing its earnings above a reasonable owner salary, and support is then set using the owner’s total earnings, the same income stream can end up counted twice: once as property and again as income. The salary the valuation assumes and the income used for support should be reconciled, and Bair shows that appellate courts will correct a judgment that counts the same dollars twice. See our pages on alimony and child support, and our child support calculator.

6. Who keeps the business, and how the other spouse gets paid

One of the statutory factors a court weighs is “the desirability of retaining any asset, including an interest in a business, corporation, or professional practice, intact and free from any claim or interference by the other party” (§ 61.075(1)(f)). Judges rarely want former spouses running a company together, and co-owners and lenders want it even less. The common outcomes are:

  • An offset. The owner keeps the business and the other spouse receives assets of equal value, such as the home, investment accounts or a larger share of the retirement accounts. The assets should be compared on an after-tax and after-liquidity basis.
  • An equalizing payment. Under § 61.075(10), the court can order a lump-sum payment or installments over a fixed period, and can require security and a reasonable rate of interest. Under § 61.075(2), a cash award for equitable distribution vests when the judgment is entered, does not end on remarriage or death unless the parties agree otherwise, and is a debt of the paying spouse’s estate. In Erp, the court held that interest on an equalizing payment had to run at the statutory rate from the date of the final judgment.
  • A sale. Ordering a business sold is a last resort, because a forced sale tends to destroy value and trigger taxes. It is more realistic when the business cannot otherwise support the payment or both spouses want out.
  • Continued co-ownership. Possible by agreement, but rarely ordered and rarely wise without detailed governance and buyout terms.

Third-party rights often limit the options:

  • Operating and shareholder agreements. Transfer restrictions, rights of first refusal and buy-sell provisions are common. Under § 605.0502, Florida Statutes, a person who receives a transfer of an LLC interest is entitled to distributions but not to participate in management, and a transfer that violates a restriction in the operating agreement is ineffective against anyone who knew of the restriction.
  • Buy-sell prices. A formula price in a buy-sell agreement is evidence of value, but the statutory standard is fair market value. Expect the non-owner spouse to argue that a formula set years earlier, often for a different purpose, does not reflect it.
  • Professional associations. For a practice organized as a professional association under Chapter 621, Florida law generally limits ownership to individuals licensed in that profession and to other professional entities (§ 621.09), so a non-licensed spouse usually cannot receive shares. Practice interests are almost always handled by offset or payment.
  • Business debt. Lines of credit, equipment loans and personal guarantees should be identified and assigned, with indemnification for the spouse who does not keep the business.

7. Disclosure, discovery and protecting the business during the case

The spouse who runs the business usually knows far more about it than the other spouse. Florida’s procedural rules are built to close that gap.

  • Mandatory disclosure. Under Florida Family Law Rule of Procedure 12.285, initial disclosure documents must be served within 45 days of service of the initial pleading on the respondent. They include each party’s financial affidavit and three years of personal tax returns with all schedules, W-2s and K-1s. The current rule also requires corporate, partnership and trust tax returns for the last three tax years if the party has an ownership interest in the entity. Earlier versions required those returns only for interests of 30 percent or more.
  • Beyond the rule. A real valuation usually requires general ledgers, bank and merchant statements, payroll records, shareholder loan accounts, governing documents, prior valuations, offers to buy the company, and the loan applications and personal financial statements the owner gave to banks, which often show the owner’s own view of what the company is worth. Our guide to discovery in a Florida high-asset divorce covers the tools.
  • Confidentiality. Rule 12.280 lets the court enter protective orders so that trade secrets and confidential commercial information are not disclosed, or are disclosed only in a designated way, and provides for confidentiality of court records under Florida Rule of General Practice and Judicial Administration 2.420. Customer lists and pricing can usually be protected without blocking the valuation.
  • Leveling the field. Under § 61.16, after considering both parties’ financial resources, the court can order one spouse to pay a reasonable amount of the other’s attorney’s fees, suit money and costs. In business cases that often determines whether the non-owner spouse can afford a forensic accountant. See fees and costs in divorce cases.
  • Dissipation. Intentional dissipation, waste or depletion of marital assets after the petition is filed, or within two years before, is an express factor that can justify an unequal distribution (§ 61.075(1)(i)). Diverted revenue, unusual payments to relatives, deferred billing and sudden capital spending all draw scrutiny. Temporary relief orders can preserve the status quo while the case is pending.
  • Interim distributions. On sworn motion, § 61.075(5) allows an interim partial distribution of marital assets for extraordinary circumstances, including a need for funds to pay a reasonable amount of attorney’s fees and costs.

8. Professional practices, partnerships and family companies

Medical, dental, legal and other professional practices

Personal goodwill carries the most weight here, and after Rosenberg the personal goodwill of every professional in a group practice is part of the analysis. Accounts receivable, work in process, equipment and the practice’s retirement plans still have to be valued, and licensing rules usually force an offset or payment rather than a transfer of shares.

Companies with partners or outside investors

Co-owners are not parties to the divorce, but their company’s records, agreements and cooperation often are central to it. The governing documents control what can be transferred, minority and marketability discounts come into play, and records frequently have to be obtained by subpoena. Owners should review their operating or shareholder agreement for divorce-related provisions early.

Multigenerational family businesses

Shares received from parents by gift or inheritance start out nonmarital, but a spouse who rises to a senior management role during the marriage can create a marital claim to the growth, as Robbie and Minton illustrate. How the owner spouse is paid, through salary, distributions or retained value, often decides how large that claim is.

Real estate, investment and holding companies

Entities that mainly hold property or investments are usually valued with the asset approach and appraisals of the underlying holdings. The active-versus-passive question is critical: rising property values alone may be passive, while leasing, developing and refinancing during the marriage can be active effort. Spouses in the investment industry should also see our articles on hedge fund managers and employee stock options.

9. Planning ahead: agreements and alternatives to trial

  • Prenuptial and postnuptial agreements. A valid agreement can keep a business and its growth nonmarital and can set how the business will be valued. Drafting matters: Florida courts have held that a prenuptial agreement does not waive a claim to the enhanced value of nonmarital property unless the waiver is unambiguous. Worley v. Worley, 855 So. 2d 632 (Fla. 2d DCA 2003). See our article on Florida Statute 61.079 and prenuptial agreements.
  • Collaborative divorce. Florida’s Collaborative Law Process Act (§§ 61.55–61.58) provides a confidential, out-of-court process, and many collaborative cases use a neutral financial professional, which can reduce the cost of dueling valuations.
  • Mediation. Business cases settle more often once both sides have a credible valuation in hand. A mediator with experience in business valuation can help the parties work through the numbers.

What is different in Palm Beach County

Divorces in Palm Beach County are heard by the Unified Family Court of the Fifteenth Judicial Circuit, with family divisions at the Main Courthouse (205 N. Dixie Highway, West Palm Beach), the North County Courthouse (3188 PGA Boulevard, Palm Beach Gardens), the South County Courthouse (200 W. Atlantic Avenue, Delray Beach) and the West County Courthouse (2950 State Road 15, Belle Glade). Administrative Order 5.101 assigns cases to those regions largely by where the parties live.

A few local practices matter in business cases:

  • Financial affidavits before mediation. Under the circuit’s family mediation order, Administrative Order 5.208, current financial affidavits for both parties must be filed before a case can be referred to the circuit’s Alternative Dispute Resolution office. Parties may instead choose a private mediator certified in family mediation, which is common in business cases.
  • Pre-trial mediation. Some divisions’ trial orders require the parties to attend a pre-trial mediation no later than 30 days before trial, even if they mediated earlier. Valuation reports need to be finished well before that date.
  • Appeals go to the Fourth District. The Fourth District Court of Appeal, headquartered in West Palm Beach, hears appeals from the Fifteenth, Seventeenth and Nineteenth Judicial Circuits. Many of Florida’s leading goodwill and enhancement decisions, including Held, Christians, Walton, Schmidt, Pereboom, Robbie and Witt-Bahls, are Fourth District cases.

The local business mix also shapes these cases. We regularly see physician and dental groups, wealth-management and investment firms, construction and real estate development companies, marine and hospitality businesses, and Wellington’s equestrian operations, along with owners who moved to Palm Beach County while their companies stayed headquartered in another state. An out-of-state company is still valued and divided in a Florida divorce, but getting its records may require subpoena procedures in the state where it is based. Our Florida divorce roadmap shows where valuation fits in the overall case, and we work with clients from West Palm Beach, Palm Beach, Jupiter, Palm Beach Gardens, Wellington, Boca Raton and the rest of the county. For larger estates, see our page on high-net-worth divorce.

Frequently asked questions

Is my business marital property if I started it before we got married?

The business itself is generally nonmarital if you owned it before the marriage. But any increase in its value during the marriage that resulted from either spouse’s efforts or from marital money is marital under section 61.075(6)(a)1.b., Florida Statutes. The spouse claiming that enhancement has the burden of proving it, which usually requires valuations as of the date of the marriage and as of the valuation date.

Will a Florida court make my spouse and me co-own the business after the divorce?

Rarely. Courts consider the desirability of keeping a business intact and free from interference by the other spouse. The usual result is that the spouse who runs the business keeps it and the other spouse receives other assets or an equalizing payment, which the court can order as a lump sum or as installments with security and interest.

Is goodwill divided in a Florida divorce?

Enterprise goodwill is divided; personal goodwill is not. Enterprise goodwill belongs to the business and would survive without the owner. Personal goodwill depends on the owner’s own presence and reputation. Since July 1, 2024, the statute says evidence that a buyer would require a noncompete must be considered but does not, by itself, rule out enterprise goodwill.

Can my spouse count the retained earnings in my S corporation as my income?

Not automatically. Under Zold v. Zold, 911 So. 2d 1222 (Fla. 2005), undistributed pass-through income retained for corporate purposes is not income for alimony or child support. The shareholder spouse bears the burden of proving the earnings were retained for corporate purposes, so an owner who controls distributions should be ready to document why money stayed in the company.

Do I need a business valuation expert?

In most contested cases, yes. A Florida judgment must identify and individually value significant marital assets based on competent substantial evidence, and valuations without that support are a frequent reason for reversal on appeal. A credentialed valuation expert or forensic accountant is usually how that evidence gets in front of the judge.

Can a prenuptial agreement protect my business?

Yes, if it is drafted carefully. A valid premarital agreement can keep a business and its growth nonmarital and can set how the business will be valued. Florida courts have held that a prenuptial agreement does not waive a claim to the enhanced value of nonmarital property unless the waiver is unambiguous, so the agreement should address growth in value expressly.

Talk with a Palm Beach County divorce attorney about your business

A business is often the largest asset in a divorce and the easiest one to misvalue. Whether you own the company and want to protect it, or you helped build it and want a fair share, we can help you identify what is marital, test or defend the valuation, sort out owner income for support purposes, and structure a division the business can actually live with. Consultations are by appointment only.

Law Offices of James S. Cunha, P.A.
250 S. Australian Avenue, Suite 1402
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
(561) 429-3924 · Contact us online

This article provides general information about Florida law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Rules and procedures change; consult an attorney about your situation.

Scroll to Top